Skip to main content

BBC - The Darwin Debate - Steven Pinker, Jonathan Miller, Steve Jones and Meredith Small

The Darwin Debate is a ~50 min 1998 BBC show. It is not the typical documentary but a round table with four panelists and Melvyn Bragg acting as the host. Bragg is just moderating the debate of the panel composed of Steven Pinker, a renown cognitive scientist, psychologist, and linguist;  Jonathan Miller, medical doctor, theater and opera director, actor, etc.; Steve Jones, geneticist specialized in evolution; and Meredith Small, a biological anthropologist. The panelists engage in very deep questions emerging from the analysis of Darwin's theory of natural selection in contemporary times. They often disagree (!), and there are several attempts of speculating about features of culture and society as if they were stemming from evolution. Indeed, The Darwin Debate is not only intended to be an accurate discussion on data and evidence, but it is aiming at performing an intellectual exercise to trigger some awareness on the limits and daily-life implications of Darwin theories. I strongly recommend you to watch it calmly, to pay attention to each standpoint. It is amazing to see how the profession and background shape (bias?) the speech of the panelists as well as their way of assuming the debate.

Enjoy!


Comments

  1. Do you know when was this recorded. I have the feeling that there are already answers for some of their speculations.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Slow science/publishing and educational system

Guys, I don't know if you already know about the ''Slow science movement'' or not, well this is a wiki definition for it: Slow science  is part of the broader  slow movement . It is based on the belief that  science  should be a slow, steady, methodical process, and that scientists should not be expected to provide "quick fixes" to society's problems. Slow science supports  curiosity -driven  scientific research  and opposes  performance targets . I'm personally interested in it if you remember Gabriel once we had a discussion on the waste of energy and resources to produce junk science and the fact that scientists are losing balance on looking into science.  Sometimes people do not know why they publish and for the sake of what?! it's become a tradition or kinda religion.  I'm most agreed with the directed scientific activities, slowly going ahead and touching the problem, whenever you can swallow the problem with...

La pioggia nel pineto (Gabriele D'Annunzio) - declaimed by Roberto Herlitzka

Since Federico is not contributing yet, I will post one of his suggestions on Italian poetry. This is a declamation (more than a reading) by Roberto Herlitzka, and it is part of the Vittorio Gassman's personal anthology of recited poetry from Italian authors. Feel the bucolic environment and the euphemistically romantic tensions. And then, the crescendo...

Firing Line - Thomas Sowell with William F. Buckley, Jr. (1981)

Firing Line is a TV show from the US I discovered just a few days ago. It is always conducted by William F. Buckley, Jr. of whom it has been said to be  "arguably the most important public intellectual in the United States in the past half-century…".   The program is a talk show based upon the interview of top level intellectual figures from the US and abroad on different topics. It has the nice quality of being intellectually challenging while often dealing with highly polemic issues. See Hoover institution archives on Firing Line broadcasts for more features and details. In particular, the interview with Prof. Thomas Sowell in 1981 (entitled "The economic lot of minorities") contains a profound debate supported with lots of data on race and gender discrimination, and how unemployment and low income rates relate to education in ethnic minorities and women. I hope you reflect on these difficult points, which are still unresolved 36 years after this interview. ...